It originated in us supreme
case Marbury vs Madison case 1803.
ð Thomas
Jefferson defeated John Adam in the presidential election of 1800.
ð Before
the Jafferon could, Adam and formally enter the office, Adam and congress passed
an Act, Judiciary Act, 1801 just one day Prior to the oath. This Act created many
new courts and requested the appointment of new judges. So, before Jefferson took
office on march 4 1801, Adams and congress passed the court adding judges and
giving the president more control over the appointment
of judges. As he used the Act of appointing 16 new circuit judges and 42 new
justices of the peace. The appointees were delivered by the senate, but they
would not be valid until commissions were delivered by the secretary of state.
ð William
Marbury has been appointed justice of the peace in the district of Columbia
but his commission was not delivered Marbury petitioned the supreme court to compel
the new secretary of state James Madison to deliver the document Marbury joined three others
ð Similarly
situated appointees, petitioned for a writ of madamus compelling the delivery
of the commission.
ð It
was necessary for final appointments that all these appointees should be delivered
their commissions from the secretary of state.
ð At
the time secretary of state was James Madison who was ordered by Jafferon to
not deliver commissions.
ð So
Madison refused to deliver the commissions.
ð One
of the persons among the appointees was William Marbury of whose commission was
also not delivered by Madison.
ð Mardury
filed a writ of mandamus in the supreme court of the USA.
The decision of the supreme court:
Madison’s recusals of delivery of
commission are illegal but the court didn’t order for delivery.
ð Supreme
court wrote in the Judgment that the Judiciary Act 1789 through which Marbury filed a writ of mandaus is against the constitution and congress does not have the
power to legislate against the constitution in the regular legislation hence Judiciary
Act 1789 is void