Group Discussion Board

Problems of ADR

Problems of ADR

by Mt.Tania Nahar (Priyanka) -
Number of replies: 1

Consent of the parties

 

For ADR to be successful, especially in arbitration proceedings, both the parties must agree to refer the dispute to be settled through arbitration or mediation. Under the Arbitration Act, 2001 if one party does not respond to the other party’s notice requesting arbitration to solve a particular dispute, the system provided by the current Act of 2001 as regards appointment of an arbitrator through Court on behalf of the non-responding party is very cumbersome and sometimes it takes years together to even get the arbitration tribunal constituted and the hearing started. So, it is basically, going through the same saga if both the parties do not agree to ADR.

 

Lack of precise Rules 

 

Since no specific Rules of Procedure have been framed for arbitration, the parties are to depend on the Rules of arbitration determined by a Tribunal. This lacuna in the system makes ADR an uncertain game.

 

No appeal on merit

 

Even if a party is not satisfied with the merit of the outcome of a resolution of a dispute through arbitration, there is no room for filing any appeal on merit. Only an award can be set aside if it can be seen that the Tribunal was biased. This aspect of the matter sometimes deters a prospective litigant from choosing arbitration over litigation.

 

Lack of institutional support

 

Countries where the system of ADR has become successful put much emphasis on institutionalization of the system of ADR. For example, in the UK, USA, Singapore, France etc., we will find that there are so many private institutions which offer institutional support for ADR. This is helpful because these institutions have their separate Rules of procedure and panel of Arbitrators. They have their own system of arranging the whole arbitration in their own way. The parties simply write to them referring a dispute and they do the rest. Some of the big names are London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA), Singapore International Arbitration Center, Hong Kong International Arbitration Center, Indian Council of Arbitration etc.. In Bangladesh we have Bangladesh Council of Arbitration (BCA), Bangladesh International Arbitration Center (BIAC), Dhaka International and Domestic Arbitration Center (DIDAC) etc.. 

 

Lack of awareness

 

People will have to be made aware of the advantages of ADR and disadvantages of court based litigations. People do not have the requisite knowledge of the system. That is why the system is not becoming common in our country.

 

There are other numerous problems also, but because of time constraints I cannot mention all here.