The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive which is referred in part-4 of the Constitution
This is a Blog Forum. Please give today's class feedback here.
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Separation of Power
Bangladesh, the separation of the judiciary and its independence are constitutional mandates repeatedly declared in the judicial pronouncements; but no effective steps were taken by any governments before 2007. In order to fulfill the constitutional mandates and mandatory directions of the judgment of the , the judiciary, particularly judicial magistrate courts were formally separated from the executive on 1st November 2007. More than 12 years have gone since the formal separation of the judiciary from the executive. Under these circumstances, this paper has been conducted to reveal whether all directions of Masdar Hossain case have been implemented and true separation of the judiciary from the executive or the legislature was established.
Juvenile
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
1st amendment
Passed on 15 July 1973, the first amendment was made to the Article 47 of the constitution. The amendment inserted an additional clause, Article 47(3), that states that any law regarding prosecution or punishment of war crimes cannot be declared void or unlawful on grounds of unconstitutionality. A new Article 47A was also added, which specifies that certain fundamental rights will be inapplicable in those cases.
Juvenile delinquency
By,Jannatul Ferdous Annisa, monday,20 November 2023,11:38pm
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Juvenile delinquency
By,Jannatul Ferdous Annisa, monday,20 November 2023,11:38pm
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Juvenile delinquency
By,Jannatul Ferdous Annisa, monday,20 November 2023,11:38pm
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Feedback
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Feedback
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Feedback
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
feedback
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
case
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
The Judiciary
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh
Article 94(4)
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence
Separation of powers
Bangladesh, the separation of the judiciary and its independence are constitutional mandates repeatedly declared in the judicial pronouncements; but no effective steps were taken by any governments before 2007. In order to fulfill the constitutional mandates and mandatory directions of the judgment of the , the judiciary, particularly judicial magistrate courts were formally separated from the executive on 1st November 2007. More than 12 years have gone since the formal separation of the judiciary from the executive. Under these circumstances, this paper has been conducted to reveal whether all directions of Masdar Hossain case have been implemented and true separation of the judiciary from the executive or the legislature was established.
Case
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
case
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Case
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Case
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Case
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Case
Juvenile is a term connected with young people who are not yet adults and silly and more typical of a child than an adult. Juvenile delinquent means and includes a young person who is not yet adult and who is guilty of committing a crime.
poverty
2. Broken family
3. Absence of parents love
4. Social transition
Bangladesh, the separation of the judiciary and its independence are constitutional mandates repeatedly declared in the judicial pronouncements; but no effective steps were taken by any governments before 2007. In order to fulfill the constitutional mandates and mandatory directions of the judgment of the , the judiciary, particularly judicial magistrate courts were formally separated from the executive on 1st November 2007. More than 12 years have gone since the formal separation of the judiciary from the executive. Under these circumstances, this paper has been conducted to reveal whether all directions of Masdar Hossain case have been implemented and true separation of the judiciary from the executive or the legislature was established.
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Independence of judiciary is the most talked about topic after the 16th Amendment case. In the verdict of 799 pages, Chief Justice has placed his observations on the BD government system. His observation, aimed at the country's legislative and executive branches, portrays the de facto role of the Judiciary to evaluate both the legislative and executive branches of our country.
However, Judiciary holds the potential to declare laws, approved by the legislative branch, null and void. Does the doctrine of judicial review (Marbury vs Madison) allow the judiciary to evaluate the performance of both the legislative and executive branches?
Though in the 16th Amendment case judgement, Chief Justice used his 'right to criticise the government' which falls within the ambit of 'freedom of expression' (Mthembi-Mahanyelevs Mail & Guardian Ltd & Another).
Independence of judiciary
Independence of judiciary is the most talked about topic after the 16th Amendment case. In the verdict of 799 pages, Chief Justice has placed his observations on the BD government system. His observation, aimed at the country's legislative and executive branches, portrays the de facto role of the Judiciary to evaluate both the legislative and executive branches of our country.
However, Judiciary holds the potential to declare laws, approved by the legislative branch, null and void. Does the doctrine of judicial review (Marbury vs Madison) allow the judiciary to evaluate the performance of both the legislative and executive branches?
Though in the 16th Amendment case judgement, Chief Justice used his 'right to criticise the government' which falls within the ambit of 'freedom of expression' (Mthembi-Mahanyelevs Mail & Guardian Ltd & Another).
Independence judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Independence of Bangladesh judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Separation of powers
Bangladesh, the separation of the judiciary and its independence are constitutional mandates repeatedly declared in the judicial pronouncements; but no effective steps were taken by any governments before 2007. In order to fulfill the constitutional mandates and mandatory directions of the judgment of the , the judiciary, particularly judicial magistrate courts were formally separated from the executive on 1st November 2007. More than 12 years have gone since the formal separation of the judiciary from the executive. Under these circumstances, this paper has been conducted to reveal whether all directions of Masdar Hossain case have been implemented and true separation of the judiciary from the executive or the legislature was established.
Separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Parliamtary
A parliamentary system is a system of democratic governance of a state where the executive derives its democratic legitimacy from its ability to command the confidence of the legislature (a parliament) and is also held accountable to that parliament.
Separation of power
Bangladesh, the separation of the judiciary and its independence are constitutional mandates repeatedly declared in the judicial pronouncements; but no effective steps were taken by any governments before 2007. In order to fulfill the constitutional mandates and mandatory directions of the judgment of the , the judiciary, particularly judicial magistrate courts were formally separated from the executive on 1st November 2007. More than 12 years have gone since the formal separation of the judiciary from the executive. Under these circumstances, this paper has been conducted to reveal whether all directions of Masdar Hossain case have been implemented and true separation of the judiciary from the executive or the legislature was established.
Separation of powers
Bangladesh, the separation of the judiciary and its independence are constitutional mandates repeatedly declared in the judicial pronouncements; but no effective steps were taken by any governments before 2007. In order to fulfill the constitutional mandates and mandatory directions of the judgment of the , the judiciary, particularly judicial magistrate courts were formally separated from the executive on 1st November 2007. More than 12 years have gone since the formal separation of the judiciary from the executive. Under these circumstances, this paper has been conducted to reveal whether all directions of Masdar Hossain case have been implemented and true separation of the judiciary from the executive or the legislature was established.
parliamentary form of government
The Independence of judiciary
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
The Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
The Independence of judiciary
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
The Independence of judiciary
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
The Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
The Independence of judiciary
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
TheJudiciary
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Judiciary
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Organic separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislatur
Organic separation
Organic
Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of
Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs,
namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the
Legislature (Part V) and the Legislatur
Judiciary
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Separation of power
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive which is referred in part-4 of the Constitution.
Government power
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive which is referred in part-4 of the Constitution
Government power
Government power
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive which is referred in part-4 of the Constitution
Government power
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive which is referred in part-4 of the Constitution
Separation of power
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive which is referred in part-4 of the Constitution.
Separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Separation power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Judiciary
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Judiciary
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Judiciary
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Judiciary
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh)
Organic separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislatur
Organic separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Organic separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Organic separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Separation of power
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independenc
Separation of power
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independenc
Separation of power
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independenc
Separation of power
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independenc
Separation of power
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independenc
eparation of power
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independenc
separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
organisation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature
Organization
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (
Separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Independence of Judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Organic separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Organic separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Organic separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Separation of poewr
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Independence judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Organic Separation:
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Organic Separation
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Separation of power
Organic Separation: The powers of the government of the People's Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive (part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Independence of judiciary
Independence of judiciary:
Article 94(4)asserts that: "Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions." Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Independence of judiciary
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Independence judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.
Answer
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs, namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
organic separation
The powers of the government of the People’s Republic
of Bangladesh have been entrusted to three separate and distinct organs,
namely, the executive ( part IV of the Constitution of Bangladesh), the
Legislature (Part V) and the Legislature ( Part VI).
Independence of judiciary
Article 94(4)asserts that: “Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, the Chief Justice and the other Judges shall be independent in the exercise of their judicial functions.” Financial independence is an integral part of the concept of judicial independence.